Cafe at The Old Rectory
Words by Mel Elliott
Photos by Steve Painter
The Old Rectory is a well-established and much-loved hotel in Hastings Old Town, famed for its exquisite walled garden, cream teas and spa treatments via The Beauty Rooms. In 2025 they opened a separate building in the form of the Cafe and have been serving relaxed, informal lunches there ever since.
Having eaten their spectacular Sunday roast to celebrate my husband’s birthday recently, I jumped at the chance to head back to sample their weekday menu when invited by its owner, Lionel Copley.
The cafe itself is situated in an out building to the rectory which was likely a garage in a previous life. It has bifold doors that look out onto a small terrace (perfect for summer al fresco dining). The interior is modern and relaxed rather like their menu.
The cafe prides itself on using local ingredients wherever possible, they make their own sausages, cure bacon and smoke the salmon. Bread is provided by Emmanual Hadjiandreou and their coffee comes from the Rye Bay Coffee Company. Their mushrooms are grown at Basils Fungi Farm in the Yard on Waterworks Road and all their cakes, desserts and even marmalades are made on the premises too. Like I said, they like to keep things local!
The weekday lunch menu is crowd-(and belly)pleasing, with soups, chowders and stews, mushrooms on toast, dahls, curries and sandwiches. Hot drinks, wines, beers and juices are served as well as G&Ts, Pimms and of course I can vouch for their excellent Bloody Mary.
We ventured there on a crisp but sunny Thursday and it was fairly busy, with a couple of tables having an impromptu lunch whilst some patrons had just popped in for a cup of tea, a slice of cake and a catchup. Walk-ins are very much encouraged here but I would advise booking for large parties, special occasions, Sundays and evenings.
What we ate:
Sausage patty, fried egg and Mayfield Swiss cheese served in an English muffin.
This came with a homemade brown sauce on the side.
Hot smoked salmon, spinach, poached egg and hollandaise on sourdough.
Breakfast Bao: Two bao, sausage patty, bacon jam, mayonnaise and a tonkatsu sauce.
Malay chicken and potato curry served with roti.


How we found room for a baked cheesecake and a slice of coconut and blueberry loaf from the dessert trolley I do not know!
Needless to say that everything was absolutely delicious, well prepared and lovingly served with great attention to detail. Portions are just right: big enough to fill but not to overface.
Sunday Lunch
If you’re heading there for a Sunday luch, you can expect to choose from 28-day aged sirloin of beef, free range roast chicken, slow roast free range port belly or nut roast: all served with rosemary roast potatoes, Yorkshire pudding, cauliflower cheese, glazed star-anise carrots and a trio of seasonal vegetables.
Evenings
On Thursday, Friday and Saturday evenings (6-9pm), celebrated chef Rob Hills of Orchard Road takes over the Cafe with his East-Asian inspired menu. The menus showcase the bold Singaporean flavours that Hills is known for. You can expect his celebrated freshly made bao, his popular Singaporean butter chicken, and his absolute signature dish: a rich, slow-cooked Beef Rendang.
Check out Cafe at The Old Rectory’s Christmas menus too!
A huge thanks to The Old Rectory for inviting us for lunch. I will definitely be heading back there at any opportunity! It’s the perfect place to call in after a stroll around the Old Town, to go for a celebration with family and friends or for a cosy evening dinner.






Comments